Module 3
1. In your
own words, explain the theory of Symbolic Interactionism.
Under
symbolic interactionism, a thing on its own does not bear any meaning but is a
symbol, the meaning of which is conferred on it by two or more people who
interact with each or one another about the said thing, opening it to a process
of interpretation that has consequences on behaviors including communicative
ones (Denzin, 2004).
2. Give an
original, real-world example of how Symbolic
Interactionism works.
In April
2016, a friar in a white robe walked into a school campus in the United States,
indirectly causing a stir after a photograph of him was uploaded to Twitter
with a caption stating that a member of the Ku Klux Klan with a whip was at
large (Leeds, 2016).
It turned out
that the man was a priest wearing his uniform, the traditional habit of the
Dominican order, with a large rosary.
The alarm
that the sight of the habit and rosary triggered was a subjective
interpretation of the items that provoked the posting of the cautionary tweet.
The subsequent clarification about the meaning of the habit and rosary, which
led to the deletion of the tweet, was a moment of interaction in which the
items were reinterpreted.
3. How might
those who understand quiddity argue with the assertions of the theory of
Symbolic Interactionism?
Quiddity
refers to the what-ness of a thing and implies that a thing can have a reality
that is independent of the meanings that human beings assign to it (Blackburn,
2016).
The
Philippine Medical Association reaffirmed in 2010 that the moment of
fertilization means that a new human life has begun in a mother's womb (ABS-CBN
News, 2010). This is reinforced by, among others, a scholarly publication in
medicine in 2017 marshaling scientific evidence to illustrate that the presence
of a zygote, embryo, or fetus is a human person's presence (Mlakvic and Flaman,
2017).
This is one
example through which those who understand quiddity may argue -- against
assertions that the meaning of a thing is socially negotiated -- that an object
can carry in itself a reality that can only be verified or denied (Is it
present? Is it living? Will it normally mature? Is it human?), not altered by
being taken to symbolize something else.
4. How might
you analyze the word “bes” or “besh” through the lens of Symbolic
Interactionism?
If I draw
from the canonical form of symbolic interactionism I might look for different
people (for instance, a grade school, high school, and college graduate), who
have used the word in conversations and ask each of them what the words mean to
them, where they picked up the word from, where they think the word comes from,
what are the contexts in which they use the word, and how it became part of
their colloquialisms.
I would then
be able to compare the evolution of the words, trace the development of their
meanings, and document and analyze their effects across the lives of three
different persons.
If I draw
from contemporary symbolic interactionism that has taken a narrative turn, I
might observe how the word is used if at all in the Thinking Pinoy (man) and
the Pinoy Ako (woman) blogs as part of their respective narratives about the
administration of President Rodrigo Duterte to ground my analysis of meaning in
reflexive, situated, and gendered contexts (Denzin, 2004).
5. How might
you analyze mask as an object during the covid-19 pandemic through the lens of
Symbolic Interactionism?
I can
interview a Republican registered voter and a Democrat registered voter about
their views of the mask during the covid-19 pandemic to obtain a possible
variety of meanings of the mask and a variegated pictures of its effects in the
lives of US citizens.
I can also
read a Filipino and a Filipina's (gendered, racial) experiences and insights
(reflexive) recorded in their blogs (narratives) of being in a "modified
enhanced community quarantine" (situated) to determine the meanings and
effects of the mask during the pandemic (Denzin, 2004).
REFERENCES
ABS-CBN News.
(2010). Doctors warn DOH on contraceptives. ABS-CBN News. Retrieved from
https://news.abs-cbn.com/nation/12/11/10/doctors-warn-doh-contraceptives
Blackburn, S.
(2016). Quiddity. In Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy. Retrieved from
https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780199541430.001.0001/acref-9780199541430-e-2610
Denzin, N.K.
(2004). Symbolic Interactionism. In U. Flick, E. Kardorff, & I. Steinke
(Eds.), A companion to qualitative research (pp. 81-87). Sage Publications.
Retrieved from:
https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/54606836/__A_Companion_to_Qualitative_Research.pdf?1507010944=&response-content-
disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DA_Companion_to_Qualitative_Research_pdf.pdf&Expires=1599317228&Signature=gWWX3
hT76NRmTHDZFcE3bpZNFjUEhhfgoLaCMgSdwjnKShXxvlygrcpsXHOtDgV5AxIrmmfp~XbgBZesTMTcD0c5mjlU-
6FMrykwdQ8OEHZWwAZs94VowWwHAVhP9TbxRHLxQjlYBEHUSO8KfdIvBaGkcxPo-
uU6vAelw0nZc7Fmq~6HHYNyn4uaj193y1pJ- QiuCYtsWLFBNisiqGJdtQrykYriQ128vs2gE4ecJnK6qxbYXnwtekSw6Y1X6loPCQnm9hwsHe59NsZ2Kab-
2xL1F8rc65TFtcLrg5xnTTSyX4KQYHvLE5Etia6TKRjcL0xkzXHdSpYThRNGey2RfA__&Key-PairId=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA#page=96
Mlakvic, J.J.
& Flaman, P. (2017). Personhood status of the human zygote, embryo, fetus.
Linacre Q, 84(2), 130–144. doi: 10.1080/00243639.2017.1299896
Leeds, G.
(2016). EXCLUSIVE: Meet the Dominican friar mistaken for an armed KKK klansman.
The Tab. Retrieved from
https://thetab.com/us/indiana/2016/04/06/dominican-friar-1859
Comments
Post a Comment