1. In your own words, explain the theory of Relational Dialectics.
The theory of Relational Dialectics holds that people as interlocutors engage in dialogue by recognizing it between or among them as:
1.1. centripetal–centrifugal flux (interaction of forces in a relationship),
1.3 aesthetic moment (temporary occasions of integration of interpenetrating, differing discourses between or among interlocutors), and
1.2 utterance (messages formed by the interpenetrating values, orientations, perspectives, or ideas of interlocutors),
2. Give a brief, real-world example of the relational dialectics between a supporter and a critic of President Rodrigo Duterte.
1.4 carnival (a performance that may empower or discrown particular realities),
all of which the communicators shape (Baxter, 2004).
In October 2020, Philippine Vice President Maria Leonor Robredo (critic) lambasted presidential spokesperson Herminio Roque's (supporter) request for University of the Philippines research group Octa to stop publicizing recommendations from their studies of the covid-19 pandemic in the country (Antonio, 2020).
Malacañang is the centripetal force trying to draw the conversation about experts' recommendations toward itself to fit its interests and the Vice President is the centrifugal force steering the conversation away from the center of power.
The contradicting positions of the two officials interpenetrated into an utterance about what could be good for the people.
Seen as carnival (in medieval Europe the carnival was an occasion when princes and paupers traded places), the Vice President in the dialogue is discrowning the administration's notion of a united position on the use of recommendations, a position that is all about imposing what it wants on academia. Discrowning a tyrannical unity (stating that a gag request may be used to enable the government to contradict science), she promotes a division that protects the sovereign people.
There is no aesthetic moment in the dialogue because the interlocutors' interpenetrating positions have not congealed into a coherent whole.
3. What might comprise the relational dialectics between a person living with HIV and his girlfriend? Use the Relational Dialectics theory as your analytical framework.
Their love for (along with any impulse to be indifferent toward) each other and how they constitute it is an utterance between them, which they will configure according to their medical histories, principles and other backgrounds.
Among many potential similar forces, the virus can be the centrifugal force regulating physical intimacy between the two while their physical proximity can be a centripetal force inclining them toward sexual activity (assuming that they are not committed to purity or abstinence ab initio).
A joint commitment to be faithful to one another forever and to seek mutual healing in body and spirit or to decide to separate peacefully can be an aesthetic moment in their dialogue.
Relational dialectics appears to be more an interpretive than an objective sort of theory (Griffins, 2012). To analyze the relational dialectics between the two celebrities, I can first gather the publicly available artifacts in which they or others refer to their relationship with each other such as journalistic reports, tweets, Facebook and Instagram posts, and photographs and videos on the internet.
Their dialogue can be a carnival in which the idea that they stick to one another only in times of health and sickness is discrowned, so that they instead privilege being there for one another in sickness and in health. The opposite, in which sticking together is experienced as oppressive and needs to be discrowned is also possible.
4. and 5. Methodologically, how might you analyze the relational dialectics between Catriona Gray and Clint Bondad? What might be the challenges and opportunities to how you conduct such an analysis?
Antonio, R. (2020, October 18). Robredo hits Roque’s gag request to Octa Research Group. Manila Bulletin. Retrieved from https://mb.com.ph/2020/10/18/robredo-hits-roques-gag-request-to-octa-research-group/
I would face the challenge of being as precise as I can be while I closely read and interpret the available items and make my conclusions. But how I conduct my analysis without interviewing either party would also be an opportunity to demonstrate that Relational Dialectics is useful for analysis of even of dialogue via evidence of it.
REFERENCES
Baxter, L.A. (2004). A tale of two voices: Relational Dialectics Theory. The Journal of Family Communication, 4(3&4), 181-192. https://doi.org/10.1080/15267431.2004.9670130
Griffin, E.A. (2012). A first look at communication theory (8th ed.). McGraw-Hill. Retrieved from: http://rosalia.mercubuana-yogya.ac.id/wp- content/uploads/2016/04/ebooksclub.org__A_First_Look_at_Communication_Theory___8th_Edition_.pdf
Comments
Post a Comment