Module 1
QUESTION 1: In your own
words, what is theory?
ANSWER: Drawing from Abend
and Nixon, I define theory as a testable assertion about a reality, provoked by
it, that is used to explain, describe, interpret, analyze, view, judge and shape,
or problematize it (Abend, 2008; Nixon, 2004).
QUESTION 2: In your own
words, explain the different views about what theory is.
ANSWER: Views about what
theory is differ in sociology and in scholarship about professional practice.
Homans maintains that theory
is exclusively a deductive tool composed of propositions about the relations
between properties of a phenomenon (Homans, 1946a in Abend, 2008).
Similarly, Turner states
that theory is exclusively a principle that governs a phenomenon regardless of
its position in time and space (Turner, 1985 in Abend, 2008).
Collins, contrary to Homans
and Turner, holds that theory is no different from sufficiently important
empirical research (Collins, 1998 in Abend, 2008).
Albrow further broadens the
definition of theory to include counting, stating that theory is the connection
of ideas (Albrow 1999, in Abend, 2008).
In comparison to Albrow,
Camic and Gross try to be more nuanced, acknowledging that theory is fuzzy but
may mean whatever it does to different sociologists considered as one family
(Camic and Gross 1998 in Abend, 2008).
Levine, however, eschews
what Abend calls the Socratic error that looks for only one definition of
theory but instead disambiguates it as a word with four senses, namely, theory
as (1) abstraction about, (2) generalization about, (3) contemplation of, and
(4) exegesis of a subject (Abend, 2008; Levine, 1997 in Abend, 2008).
Like Levine, Abend says, Alexander examines
theory as a semantic problem but reaches a separate conclusion: that theory is
simply a label such that at any point on the metaphysical-empirical continuum,
items to the left (more metaphysical), may be called theories and items to the
right (more empirical), may be called data (Abend, 2008; Alexander, 1982 in
Abend, 2008).
Merton, at first, appears to
be pluralist and states that in sociology, theory can mean six different
things, but Abend says that in the end, Merton excludes from his definition of
theory methodology, general orientations, conceptual analysis, post factum interpretations,
and empirical generalizations (Merton, 1945 in Abend, 2008).
Abend argues for pluralism, saying that
whether theory is (1) a general proposition, (2) an explanation, (3)
sense-making, (4) textual analysis, (5) world interpretation, (6) norm
promotion, or (7) systematic discourse about social phenomena it should be
accepted by sociologists (Abend, 2008).
Nixon, meanwhile, embeds
theory not in research but in professional practice, stating that it is an aid
to contemplation that helps a professional interpret an act, evaluate and
consider alternatives to it, and explain it to give space to better actions if
necessary (Nixon, 2004).
QUESTION 3: For the purposes
of the humanities and social sciences, which definition or definitions of
theory are most useful?
ANSWER: All the definitions
of theory presented by Abend, including those of the sources he cites, and by
Nixon are most useful for the humanities and social sciences (Abend, 2008;
Nixon, 2004). The most useful mode of theory for the researcher is the one that
best helps him answer his social science or humanities research question.
QUESTION 4: In your own
words, what is the relationship between theory and research?
ANSWER: Theory inspires me
to pose a research question, curate and review related literature, develop a
study framework, select a research methodology, implement a study, reflect on
findings, contribute to theory, and generate questions for further research.
QUESTION 5: What are the
marks of a good theory?
ANSWER: According to Nixon,
for a theory to be good in the context of professional practice, it should
enable me to understand, judge, and adjust my actions so that I may become a
better professional and human being (Nixon, 2004). [N.B. For more answers to
this question, not required to answer it in this module but pertinent to the
second module, see Griffin (2012) on the characteristics of good objective and
interpretive theories in the discipline of communication].
References
Abend, G. (2008). The
meaning of theory. Sociological Theory, 26(2), 173-199. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/227496484_The_Meaning_of_%27Theory%27 Nixon, J. (2004).
What is theory? Educar, 24,
27-37. DOI: 10.5565/rev/educar.232
Comments
Post a Comment